THD and ITHD in PMSM and BLDC Motor Drive Design

1. THD (Total Harmonic Distortion)

• Definition: THD is the ratio of the sum of the powers (or RMS values) of all harmonic components to the power (or RMS value) of the fundamental frequency component in a signal. It's typically expressed as a percentage (%).

• Scope: THD is a general term and can refer to the distortion in either a voltage waveform (THDv) or a current waveform (THDi). If not specified, the context usually dictates which one is meant.

  • For audio amplifiers or the output of power supplies/inverters, "THD" usually refers to the voltage distortion (THDv) of the output signal.

• Significance: A lower THD value indicates that the waveform is closer to a pure sine wave, meaning less distortion.

  • Audio Equipment: Low THD (voltage) is crucial for high fidelity sound reproduction, meaning the output sound is very close to the original recording without added unwanted tones.

  • Power Supplies/Inverters: Low THD (voltage) in the AC output signifies better power quality, which is less likely to cause issues for connected appliances.

​

2. ITHD (Total Harmonic Distortion of Current)

• Definition: ITHD specifically refers to the Total Harmonic Distortion of the current waveform. It measures the ratio of the RMS value of all harmonic currents to the RMS value of the fundamental current, expressed as a percentage. It's often written as THDi or THD-I.

• Scope: Measures the distortion present in the current drawn by an electronic device from the power source (e.g., the mains grid) or injected into the grid.

• Significance: ITHD is critically important for assessing the impact of electronic devices, especially non-linear loads, on power quality.

  • Non-linear loads (like Switch-Mode Power Supplies (SMPS) in computers and chargers, rectifiers, Variable Frequency Drives (VFDs), LED drivers, dimmers) draw current that is not sinusoidal, even if the supply voltage is a perfect sine wave. This distorted current contains significant harmonics.

  • Consequences of High ITHD:

    • Harmonic currents flow back into the power grid, potentially distorting the grid voltage itself, affecting other users.

    • Increased heating and losses in wiring, transformers, and neutral conductors.

    • Potential interference with communication systems.

    • Reduced overall Power Factor.

    • Possible nuisance tripping of circuit breakers.

• Standards: Regulatory bodies and standards (like IEEE 519) often impose limits on the amount of harmonic current (and thus ITHD) that equipment is allowed to inject into the power grid to maintain grid stability and quality.

​

Sources of Harmonics in PMSM and BLDC Drives

Several factors contribute to the generation of harmonics in PMSM and BLDC motor drives:

• Inverter Switching: The primary source of harmonics is the Pulse Width Modulation (PWM) switching of the inverter. The switching frequency and the specific PWM strategy employed directly impact the harmonic spectrum.

• Dead Time: The necessary dead time between switching signals in the inverter legs to prevent short circuits also introduces waveform distortion and generates harmonics.

• Non-ideal Components: Non-ideal characteristics of power electronic switches, passive components, and sensing circuits can contribute to harmonic distortion.

• Motor Design (especially for BLDC): The trapezoidal back-EMF waveform of a typical BLDC motor, as opposed to the more sinusoidal back-EMF of a PMSM, naturally leads to different harmonic characteristics in the current when controlled with standard commutation techniques. Even in PMSMs, spatial harmonics in the magnetic field can contribute to current harmonics.

• Control Strategy: The specific control algorithms used to drive the motor can also influence the harmonic content of the voltage and current.

​

Impact of THD and ITHD on PMSM and BLDC Motor Performance

High levels of THD and ITHD have several detrimental effects on the performance of PMSM and BLDC motors and the overall drive system:

• Torque Ripple: Harmonic currents interact with the motor's magnetic field to produce unwanted torque pulsations. This torque ripple can lead to vibrations, acoustic noise, and reduced control precision, particularly critical in applications requiring smooth motion control. BLDC motors, due to their trapezoidal back-EMF and typically 120-degree commutation, are inherently more susceptible to torque ripple from harmonics than PMSMs driven with sinusoidal current.

• Increased Losses and Reduced Efficiency: Harmonic currents cause additional copper losses (I2R losses) in the motor windings due to the increased RMS value of the current. They also contribute to increased iron losses (eddy current and hysteresis losses) in the stator core. These extra losses lead to reduced motor efficiency and increased operating temperature, potentially shortening the motor's lifespan.

• Overheating: The increased losses due to harmonics result in higher operating temperatures for both the motor and the power electronic components of the drive. This can stress insulation materials and lead to premature failure.

• Acoustic Noise and Vibration: Torque ripple and harmonic currents contribute to increased audible noise and mechanical vibration in the motor and the driven system.

• Electromagnetic Interference (EMI): The fast switching edges and harmonic content of the voltage and current can generate electromagnetic interference, potentially affecting other sensitive electronic equipment.

• Reduced Power Quality: From the perspective of the power source, high ITHD means the motor drive draws a distorted current, which can negatively impact the voltage quality for other connected loads on the same electrical network. This is why standards like IEEE 519 set limits on harmonic distortion injected back into the grid.

​

Mitigation Strategies

To minimize the negative impacts of THD and ITHD in PMSM and BLDC drive designs, various mitigation techniques are employed, similar to those used in general motor drives but sometimes with specific considerations for the motor type:

• Advanced PWM Techniques: Implementing sophisticated PWM strategies (e.g., Space Vector Modulation for PMSM) can optimize the switching patterns to reduce specific harmonics.

• Filtering: Incorporating AC inductors on the input side (line reactors) or output side (motor reactors) of the inverter, or using more complex passive or active filters, can help attenuate harmonic currents.

• Multilevel Inverters: Using multilevel inverter topologies can produce voltage waveforms with lower harmonic content compared to standard two-level inverters.

• Control Algorithm Improvements: Implementing control strategies that actively compensate for or suppress harmonics can improve performance.

In conclusion, THD and particularly ITHD are significant concerns in PMSM and BLDC motor drive design. The switching nature of the inverter is the primary cause of these harmonics, which in turn lead to undesirable effects like torque ripple, reduced efficiency, and increased heat and noise. Careful design considerations, including appropriate PWM strategies, filtering, and potentially advanced control techniques, are essential to manage harmonic distortion and ensure optimal performance and reliability of PMSM and BLDC drive systems.